Ion torrent reads were trimmed with the quality score limit set to 0. Apr 22, 2012 regarding the nature biotech paper, i do not think it was fair to compare the bottomlevel chemistry of ion torrent 100 bp reads against miseqs 150 bp pe reads. Methods such as illumina solexa sequencing, ion torrent. Salipante, a toana kawashima, a christopher rosenthal, a daniel r. Performance comparison of benchtop highthroughput sequencing platforms nature biotech. Too little dna compared to other components of the solution. Ion semiconductor sequencing is a method of dna sequencing based on the detection of hydrogen ions that are released during the polymerization of dna. Rnaseq blog in publications august 15, 2017 7,814 views though illumina has largely dominated the rnaseq field, the simultaneous availability of ion torrent has left scientists wondering which platform is most effective for differential gene. Ion personal genome machine pgm and miseq were launched by ion torrent and illumina.
For most organisms, illumina data had a higher fraction of reads with perfect quality than did the ion torrent data, although for h. Here we compare the performances of two common benchtop sequencing platforms, illumina miseq and ion torrent personal genome machine pgm, for bacterial community profiling by 16s rrna v1v2 amplicon sequencing. Comparison of illumina miseq and the ion torrent pgm and s5. Eventually, ion torrent technology will also be able to provide diagnostics that are less expensive and more reliable, improving human health around the world. Comparison of illumina miseq and ion torrent pgm for next.
A comparison of illumina and ion torrent sequencing platforms, and the winner is posted by. Comparison of illumina miseq and ion torrent pgm for nextgeneration sequencing of rna viruses abstract nextgeneration sequencing ngs technology is becoming a powerful tool in a public health setting for virus surveillance. Nextgeneration sequencing is a powerful tool for virological surveillance. Ion torrent from life technologies has two instruments. While illumina and ion torrent sequencing platforms are used extensively for generating viral rna genome sequences, there is limited data. We incorporated the three variants callers torrent variant caller tvc, mutect2 and varscan2 in a pipeline that normalises all resulting variants so that variants are left aligned and represented using the most parsimonious alleles, which allows comparison of both snvs and indels. We evaluated the illumina miseq, ion torrent pgm and ion torrent s5 platforms using a panel of sixteen specimens containing picornaviruses and. Though illumina has largely dominated the rnaseq field, the simultaneous availability of ion torrent has left scientists wondering which. The method relies on the detection of hydrogen ions released during the dna polymerization reaction. Illumina uses reversible terminated nucleotides delivered a. The pace of change in this area is rapid with three major new sequencing platforms having been released in 2011. Pdf comparison of illumina miseq and the ion torrent pgm and. But illumina has plenty of competition in the contest for accurate, fast and cheap sequencing. Hayer7, tapan ganguly5,8, jonathan schug3,4 and gregory r.
The biggest difference is that we can go down to 10ng of dna on the ion torrent platform and still get good results, even if the quality is lower. Illumina amplifies individual library molecules on a solid surface to form polonies ion torrent uses emulsion pcr on beads they were working on another scheme. Transitioning from ion torrent to illumina ngs platforms. Proton pgm sequencing, illumina miseq and solid sequencing have revolutionized genomic and genetic research. I admit my own bias, and for today suffice it to say that each platform in terms of technology has an accuracy rate on the order of 99%, with the majority of the bases on each run 7080% of the bases. For the ion torrent pgm platform against the illumina miseq platform, a bit of a marketing war has erupted, with both sides trading barbs. What is the difference between ion torrent and illumina. The complete sampletoanswer system uses dedicated library preparation kits, customized instrument control software, and an analytical software package to support the reliable analysis of both routine and. Ion pgm was released by ion torrent at the end of 2010. Nextgeneration sequencing ngs technology is becoming a powerful tool in a public health setting for virus surveillance.
Comparative analysis of illumina and ion torrent high. Comparison of illumina miseq and ion torrent pgm for nextgeneration sequencing of rna viruses abstract. A comparison of illumina and ion torrent sequencing platforms. Jul 30, 2014 performance comparison of illumina and ion torrent nextgeneration sequencing platforms for 16s rrnabased bacterial community profiling stephen j. Lahens1, emanuela ricciotti1,2, olga smirnova3,4, erik toorens5, eun ji kim1, giacomo baruzzo6, katharina e. Reads from both illumina platforms, gaii and hiseq, were trimmed with a quality score limit of 0. Here we compare the results obtained with those platforms to the performance of the illumina hiseq, the current market leader. We analysed the bacterial diversity in the rumen of defaunated sheep following the introduction of different protozoal populations, using both next generation sequencing ngs. A comparison of illumina and ion torrent sequencing platforms, and the winner is august 15, 2017 1 comment 7,776 views though illumina has largely dominated the rnaseq field, the simultaneous availability of ion torrent has left scientists wondering which platform is most effective for differential gene expression dge analysis. Table 1 from a tale of three next generation sequencing. Pros and cons of iontorrent next generation sequencing. Pdf nextgeneration sequencing is a powerful tool for virological surveillance. Comparison of ion torrent, pacific biosciences and. A comparison of illumina and ion torrent platforms in.
Regarding the nature biotech paper, i do not think it was fair to compare the bottomlevel chemistry of ion torrent 100 bp reads against miseqs 150 bp pe reads. The equipment needed for performing an ampliseq for illumina library prep is the same as the equipment needed for performing an ampliseq library experiment on the ion torrent. Jul 26, 2016 though illumina has largely dominated the rnaseq market, the emergence of ion torrent in recent years has left scientists wondering which platform is bestsuited for rnaseq analysis. Backgroundnext generation sequencing ngs technology has revolutionized genomic and genetic research. Ion torrent pgm and terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism t.
The development of next generation sequencing has challenged the use of other molecular fingerprinting methods used to study microbial diversity. Ion torrent reads have variable lengths due to homopolymers and the correspondence of flow order to sequence if the flow order was a,t,c,g and the sequence of two fragments atcg and gcta, the former will read in all four flows but the latter only in the fourth flow. View benchtop and productionscale sequencer comparison tables, and find tools designed to help you choose the right platform for your needs. The miseq fgx forensic genomics system is the first fully validated sequencing system designed for use in forensic genomics applications. Apr 22, 2012 comparison of homopolymer accuracy between ion torrent pgm and 454 gs junior demonstrated that ion torrent pgm was less accurate when calling homopolymers of any length supplementary fig. While illumina and ion torrent sequencing platforms are used extensively for generating viral rna genome sequences, there is limited data comparing different platforms. In order to make the comparison fair, the authors should have used ion torrent 100 bp pe vs miseqs 150 bp pe reads, or ion torrent 100 bp vs miseqs nonpe. For a comparison of illumina sequencing systems, see the. Illumina benchtop sequencing consumables are single cartridgebased with a separate flow cell. The personal genome machine which has been out since 2010. Each sample was sequenced on two hts platforms illumina and ion torrent in two replicates. Comparison of homopolymer accuracy between ion torrent pgm and 454 gs junior demonstrated that ion torrent pgm was less accurate when calling homopolymers of any length supplementary fig. To the best of our knowledge, this is a first direct side by side comparison of the. Salipante, toana kawashima, christopher rosenthal, daniel r.
A comparison of illumina and ion torrent platforms in a. The wellcome trust sanger institute, uk, recently published a comparison of the ion torrent pgm, illumina miseq, and pacific biosciences pacbio rs. The technology was licensed from dna electronics ltd, developed by ion torrent systems inc. Ion torrent, a division of thermofisher, has several sequencers, including the pgm and proton, which are based on detecting electrical signals from dna samples on a semiconductor chip. View benchtop and productionscale sequencer comparison tables, and find tools designed to help you. Ngs systems are typically represented by solidion torrent pgm from life sciences, genome analyzerhiseq 2000miseq from illumina, and gs flx. Previous studies comparing the two have often used reference samples derived from cell lines and brain tissue. Comparison of illumina miseq and the ion torrent pgm and. The ion proton however is capable of generating significantly larger outputs table 1 making sequencing of transcriptome, exome and medium sized genomes possible. Illumina reads in a run will all have the same untrimmed length. Salipante, atoana kawashima, christopher rosenthal, adaniel r. Jul 30, 2012 comparison of illumina miseq, ion torrent pgm, 454 gs junior and pacbio rs diagnostics joe says. Roches 454 life sciences is partnering with dna electronics on the.
Comparing the performance of three nextgen sequencers. The details of the methods used are shown in table 1. Jul 24, 2012 next generation sequencing ngs technology has revolutionized genomic and genetic research. Support center transitioning from ion torrent to illumina ngs platforms this resource provides stepbystep guidance through the process of transitioning from ion torrent to illumina nextgeneration sequencing platforms. They are targeted to clinical applications and small labs. A comparison of illumina and ion torrent sequencing. For a comparison of illumina sequencing systems, see the sequencing platform comparison tool. Pdf a tale of three next generation sequencing platforms. A tale of three next generation sequencing platforms. Aug 10, 2017 read count comparison between platforms. Comparison of ion torrent, pacific biosciences and illumina miseq sequencers article pdf available in bmc genomics 1. Comparison of somatic variant detection algorithms using. Performance comparison of benchtop highthroughput sequencing platforms nature biotech there is a rebuttal from iontorrent, the analysis section is not as much a rebuttal they are instead saying that the new kits are a lot better. Which one would you recommend illumina miseq or ion torrent pgm.
Comparison of illumina miseq, ion torrent pgm, 454 gs junior and pacbio rs diagnostics joe says. The number of reads per sample after filtering varied from 31,049 to 223,587, with 83% illumina and 75% ion torrent of the samples having more than 100,000 total reads see table 2. Next generation sequencing determines the nucleic acid sequence of millions of basepairs in hours a few days and allows for sequencing whole genomes at once. Here is a publication comparing the performance of different sequencing platforms.
Results are displayed for two representative samples il1. If a nucleotide, for example a c, is added to a dna template and is then incorporated into a strand of dna, a hydrogen ion will be. Performance and comparison of ion torrent pgm and illumina miseq. Ion torrent have marketed their machine as a rapid, compact and economical sequencer that can be utilized in a large number of laboratories as a bench top machine. These findings suggest that the ion torrent 46 s5 and illumina miseq platforms are both viable options for genomic sequencing of. Comparison of illumina miseq, ion torrent pgm, 454 gs.
Its mostly only applicable for small genome sequencing like bacterial genomes. In the dna sequencing report issued late last week from macquarie equities research, analysts jon groberg and travis steed write that illumina has made. Comparison of nextgeneration sequencing systems hindawi. Highthroughput sequencing of the taxonomically informative 16s rrna gene provides a powerful approach for exploring microbial diversity. Though illumina has largely dominated the rnaseq market, the emergence of ion torrent in recent years has left scientists wondering which platform is bestsuited for rnaseq analysis. Next generation sequencing an overview open source at. Performance comparison of illumina and ion torrent nextgeneration sequencing platforms for 16s rrnabased bacterial community pro. Two of the most common sequencing platforms are the illumina miseq and the thermofisher ion torrent.
Comparison of illumina miseq and the ion torrent pgm. There is a rebuttal from iontorrent, the analysis section is not as much a rebuttal they are instead saying that the new kits are a lot better. Next generation sequencing, also known as high throughput, massive parallel and deep sequencing, has dramatically increased the speed and reduced the cost of sequencing, making it possible to sequence a bacterial genome in just a few days and rapidly compare genetic sequences among multiple genome. Sequence generated by ion torrent, miseq and pacific biosciences.
Applications in denovo sequencing and structural variation studies. They compared the results obtained with those platforms to the performance of the illumina hiseq, the current market leader. While illumina and ion torrent sequencing platforms are used extensively for generating viral rna genome sequences, there is limited data comparing. Contact illumina technical support or your local illumina representative for more assistance with making this decision. Comparison of illumina miseq, ion torrent pgm, 454 gs junior.
Performance comparison of illumina and ion torrent nextgeneration sequencing platforms for 16s rrnabased bacterial community profiling stephen j. Here we compare the results obtained with those platforms to the performance of the illumina hiseq, the. Ion torrent nextgeneration sequencing technology us. Ion torrents pgm, pacific biosciences rs and the illumina miseq.
This is a method of sequencing by synthesis, during which a complementary strand is built based on the sequence of a template strand. Performance of the illumina and ion torrent has been compared before for 16s rrnabased bacterial community profiling salipante et al. Ion pgm has accessory equipment that might no longer be needed. But they found that there were key differences in data quality of the platforms. Reads from the illumina and ion torrent platforms were mapped against the s.
Aug 15, 2017 a comparison of illumina and ion torrent sequencing platforms, and the winner is posted by. Here we compare the results obtained with those platforms to the performance of the illumina hiseq, the current market. Jul 22, 2017 illumina amplifies individual library molecules on a solid surface to form polonies ion torrent uses emulsion pcr on beads they were working on another scheme. Its low throughput makes it ideal for smaller sized studies. Illumina miseq and iontorrent pgm technology and price comparison multiple studies and groups have compared the performance of current next generation sequencing ngs technologies. We use the illumina miseq platforms for our hematological malignancies, while we use the thermofisher ion torrent pgm and proton platform for our solid tumors. Contact your local territory account manager for assistance. A treatmentcontrol experimental design to compare platforms.
Here we compare the performances of two common benchtop sequencing platforms, illumina miseq and ion torrent personal genome machine pgm, for. Next generation sequencing ngs technology has revolutionized genomic and genetic research. A comparison of illumina and ion torrent sequencing platforms in. Jul 24, 2012 a tale of three next generation sequencing platforms.
The ion torrent proton compared to the illumina hiseq 2500. Ion torrent genexus system specimen to report in a single day with a handsoff, automated workflow the genexus system is the first turnkey ngs solution that automates the specimentoreport workflow and delivers results in a single day with just two user touchpoints. Performance comparison of illumina and ion torrent next. Sales of the ion torrent desktop sequencers exceed those of its rival miseq machine from illumina, according to a new financial report, which highlights encouraging trends for both illumina and ion torrent parent company, life technologies. Performance comparison of benchtop highthroughput sequencing. Comparison of ion torrent, pacific biosciences and illumina.
They are both small in size and feature fast turnover rates but limited data throughput. Which one would you recommend illumina miseq or ion. We sought to compare the illumina and ion torrent sequencing platforms using a treatmentcontrol experimental paradigm see methods section for details. Cluster density is referred to as loading density in the support. While illumina and ion torrent sequencing platforms are. The ion pgm ion torrent, is ideal for amplicons, small genomes or targeting of small regions within a genome.
77 706 643 601 1607 974 638 1503 1401 404 65 929 593 218 936 725 231 253 998 515 1611 994 47 1268 944 1120 1522 470 978 984 896 1011 1367 906 1311 1286 377 982 406 1406 145 839 295 863 643